Pennsylvania is moving the bar after students took the test

Pennsylvania students took their reading and math tests last spring. Now, months later, state officials want to change what their results mean.

A proposal scheduled for a November 19 state board vote would lower the scores students need to earn an “Advanced” rating on the state’s math and English assessments. The proficiency threshold would remain unchanged. But more students could be labeled Advanced—not because they learned more, but because the state changed the classification after they took the tests.

The state is also revising its descriptions of student performance, which had been in place since 2012. The old Advanced descriptor said that, “Consistent performance at this level indicates advanced academic preparation for engaging successfully in further studies.” The new version says, “the student is academically prepared for grade level instruction in the next school year.” It’s a small wording change, but it weakens the promise attached to the label.

There is a potentially defensible version of this policy. If Pennsylvania policymakers paired the revised threshold with automatic enrollment in advanced coursework, the state could make an affirmative case that it was revising its threshold to expand opportunities for students. In that scenario, the state would be saying that students scoring at the advanced level are ready for greater challenges, and schools should give them those opportunities. A broader definition of Advanced would then come with a concrete benefit to students.

But without that connection, what are students actually going to gain? A more flattering label is not the same as a more challenging education.

The timing also sends a bad signal. Pennsylvania is not announcing a new standard for future students. It is proposing to apply the new threshold to tests that students have already completed. It has also triggered a delay in finalizing last year’s results, which has caused disruptions at the local level. According to a Chalkbeat article from August, “Philadelphia teachers and principals use state test scores from the prior school year to assess student learning, roster kids into the proper classes, and prepare for the year to come.” But that couldn’t happen this year, thanks to the state’s testing delays.

Now, performance standards can and should be updated over time. But officials should do that carefully. They should explain what was wrong with the old threshold, why the new one better identifies readiness, and what will change for students as a result. On the other hand, the process Pennsylvania is following looks less like a strategy to raise achievement than a decision to lower the bar after the fact.